This seems to be a busier than usual Autumn on Broadway and off. A number of new shows are opening, plus the Metropolitan Opera hosted the world premiere of a new opera based on a recent, best-selling book. Reverend was able to attend and henceforth weigh in on a few of these:
Copperfield! The New Musical (now playing through December 6th at The Duke on 42nd Street)
You’ve gotta love the exclamation point added to this adaptation of Charles Dickens’ classic David Copperfield. Of course, Dickens’ Oliver Twist previously inspired the beloved Oliver!, one of the earliest musicals with an exclamation point at the end of the title.
At any rate, this tale of a fatherless, abused boy during the mid-19th century who grows up to become a great writer is regarded as the author’s most autobiographical story. Jeffrey Scharf has crafted some fitting, varied, but mostly unmemorable tunes with which to relate the title character’s travails. To their credit, director-choreographer Gabriel Barre and his design team have made two strong choices. One was to assemble an uber talented cast (with one notable exception, further below) who not only sing but play all the instruments. The other was to give the production a versatile, music hall/tavern-esque setting that effectively evokes various locations including—most effectively--a ship sailing to Australia in the midst of a hurricane!
Despite an overlong first act which--as my following two reviews attest--is hardly unique to this show, Reverend found Copperfield! to be a respectful and musically pleasing endeavor. Its weakest element, I’m sad to say, is leading man Bobby Conte. A veteran of such Broadway productions as The Who’s Tommy, Company and A Bronx Tale, Conte is largely sidelined here as the story’s observer/narrator. And I mean that literally: he stands on the side and scribbles into his little notebook most of the time. When he gets to sing full-on toward the show’s end, he displays an exaggerated Anthony Newley-esque vibrato.
Reverend’s Rating: B
Wanted (now playing at the James Earl Jones Theatre)
Flash forward a few decades and across the Atlantic to 1893 Texas. Angelica Cheri is currently making her impressive Broadway debut as a book writer and lyricist, together with first-timer Ross Baum as composer, with the original musical Wanted. Their show is unique both dramatically and stylistically, and with any luck will have a long, award-winning run.
It is inspired by family oral history of Cheri’s great-great aunts, Mary and Martha Clarke, who are powerfully played and sung here by (respectively) Solea Pfeiffer and Liisi LaFontaine. The two sisters were twin daughters of a former slave mother and a white father, enabling them to pass as white in racially segregated (then and now?) Texas. The musical depicts them using this to their advantage as they seek justice for abuses against their mother and ancestors.
As I write I realize this is heavy stuff, and one of the more significant true-life stories to grace Broadway to date. The musical was formerly titled Gun & Powder while in development, which I actually prefer. It alludes to both Martha’s more trigger-happy response to conflict and Mary’s desire to be fully embraced by white society, to the extent she hides her identity and marries a wealthy white landowner. The most potent moment in the show is when Mary sings “The Way I Am” while sitting in front of a mirror excessively covering herself, and even a phantom vision of her black mother, with white powder. Pfeiffer sells it unforgettably, and I hope both she and LaFontaine are honored next year with Tony Award nominations (at least).
While Wanted has some white cast members, this is a black story told by a predominantly black cast and I appreciated this. Stevie Walker-Webb’s direction and Chelsey Arce’s choreography draw this significance out all the more, especially in their utilization of an “ancestor chorus” who musically comment on events during the course of the story. There are times when, as some other critics and commentators have noted, Wanted doesn’t feel so much like being in a theater than it does being in a church. I found this aspect fantastic, as a church person myself, but can see how the less-familiar might be put off.
Cheri’s book does go on a bit long and gets convoluted (especially Act 1), and there is at least one power ballad too many in the score. But these are ultimately minor quibbles about what I feel is a very significant--potentially even historic—musical. If any of this sounds appealing, get your tickets now!
Reverend’s Rating: A-
Lincoln in the Bardo (Just ended its run at the Metropolitan Opera on November 14th)
While situated historically in the second half of the 19th century, the physical/supernatural setting of this world premiere opera by Missy Mazzoli and Royce Vavrek is most unique. It is adapted from the bestselling speculative novel by George Saunders, published in 2017, wherein US President Abraham Lincoln grieves the death of his 11 year-old son Willie. The younger Lincoln is trapped with other souls in a Purgatory-like realm referred to as the “bardo” in Tibetan Buddhism.
I had not read the book before attending the opera’s final performance at the Met but was aware a movie version starring Tom Hanks as Abe is currently in production. In short, I didn’t know what to expect. This production proved to be a disappointment dramatically and musically.
Too many seemingly extraneous supporting characters, a minimalist and often static score, and its excessive length were too much for me. Full disclosure: my companion and I left at intermission (roughly the 90 minute mark) but I watched the opera’s second act the next day on YouTube, where it is was streamed through November 18th. The free YouTube option was only announced three days before the closing performance. Had it been announced at the outset, or if the production had a Met Live simulcast during the run, we likely would have been happier to not spend as much as we did on in-person tickets.
I can’t fault the opera’s cast, who all get an A for their vocals. Soloists Peter Mattei (as the President), Christine Goerke (as the Reverend), Anthony Roth Costanzo (as Miss Elise Traynor) and Everett Sobers (as Willie in the final performance) were standouts. And while unexpected and bizarre, the production’s puppetry and Act 2 pyrotechnics kept me from falling asleep.
It is important to note that Lincoln in the Bardo was the first work by a female composer to ever premiere at the Met. That this took 140+ years, however, should be embarrassing for such a world-class opera house. Perhaps the Met has itself been in the bardo all this time.
Reverend’s Rating: C-
The Most Reverend Chris Carpenter is editor of Movie Dearest and chief contributor. He has been reviewing movies and theatre since 1996 and also contributes to Rage Monthly magazine (ragemonthly.com). He is a founding member and former Vice President of GALECA: The Society of LGBTQ Critics (galeca.com) and currently serves as a nominating/voting member of its New York City-based Theatre Wing. Reverend Carpenter has been an ordained minister since 1995.






No comments:
Post a Comment